The Best Pie in Indiana That No One Talks About

The best pies to try in Indiana
Share Post :

Rolling Pin Bakehouse, Roanoke

Mixed Berry Pie in Rolling Pin Bake House

Price Range: $3 – $5 per slice

Specialty: Mixed Berry Pie

Located in Roanoke, Rolling Pin Bakehouse epitomizes traditional baking. The highlight is the mixed berry pie, featuring meticulously selected berries for peak flavor, encased in a golden-brown crust prepared fresh daily. The bakehouse presents a cozy atmosphere akin to a grandmother’s kitchen.

Boulder Creek Dining Company, Brownsburg

Boulder Creek Dining Company in Brownsburg

Price Range: $5 – $7 per slice

Specialty: Key Lime Pie

Boulder Creek Dining Company offers Key Lime Pie, a blend of tangy richness and sweet, crumbly crust. The restaurant’s rustic decor with stone and wood complements the serene creek-side setting.

Mrs. Wick’s Pies, Winchester

Eating pie at Mrs. Wick’s Pies in Winchester

Price Range: $2.50 – $4 per slice

Specialty: Pecan Pie

Mrs. Wick’s Pies, a staple in Winchester, serves a pecan pie with toasted pecans and caramel-like filling in a flaky crust. The pie embodies southern comfort, backed by genuine hospitality.

Locally Grown Gardens, Indianapolis

Eating pie at the Locally Grown Gardens, Indianapolis

Price Range: $5 – $7 per slice

Specialty: Sugar Cream Pie

Locally Grown Gardens offers a standout sugar cream pie amidst a year-round farmers market setting. The pie combines creamy filling with a buttery crust, offering a nostalgic taste. The market enhances the pie-eating experience with its vibrant, local produce.

Leave a Comment

66  +    =  69

Latest Posts


Related Posts

Ready for more adventures? Join me as we explore the heart of Indiana, uncovering its hidden gems and unique stories. Check out my related posts and recent updates for more quirky tales and unexpected surprises. Let’s continue our journey along the corny road together!